12 AirTag Dog Collar Myths That Could Put Your Pet at Risk - Paws & Whiskers - Dog Protection Gear

12 AirTag Dog Collar Myths That Could Put Your Pet at Risk

AirTag dog collars have surged in popularity among pet owners, offering an affordable, convenient way to keep track of our furry companions. But with growing popularity comes confusion and misinformation. Myths around AirTag collars can prevent pet owners from making informed decisions to protect their pets.

In this article, we’ll debunk the most common myths about AirTag collars, clarify the facts, and ensure you know exactly how to keep your dog safe. 

Key Takeaways:

  • AirTags rely on Bluetooth and Apple's Find My network, not GPS or real-time cellular tracking.

  • AirTags don’t require any ongoing monthly fees, making them a cost-effective solution.

  • AirTags are water-resistant, not fully waterproof; limit extended water exposure.

  • Use high-quality collars designed specifically for AirTags to ensure safety and comfort.

  • AirTags complement microchips and ID tags but should never replace them.

  • Regularly test and maintain your AirTag to guarantee ongoing effectiveness.

  • AirTags are lightweight and suitable even for small breeds when paired with proper collars.

  • Remember, AirTags are not a replacement for basic obedience and recall training.

Myth #1: AirTags Work Exactly Like GPS Trackers

Many pet owners mistakenly believe AirTags function the same as traditional GPS trackers. While GPS trackers connect to satellites to provide real-time tracking, AirTags operate differently.

AirTags use Bluetooth technology and Apple's extensive “Find My” network. Rather than directly communicating with satellites, an AirTag emits a Bluetooth signal picked up by nearby Apple devices. These devices then anonymously relay the AirTag's location back to you through the Find My network.

Because of this crowd-sourced approach, the effectiveness of an AirTag largely depends on the presence of Apple devices nearby. For pet owners in urban or suburban areas, AirTags usually provide reliable tracking. But in remote or rural areas, GPS trackers might offer more reliable updates.

To dive deeper into the technology, you can explore Apple's official explanation of how AirTags work.

AirTag vs GPS dog collar

Myth #2: AirTags Have Monthly Fees

Some dog owners hesitate to adopt AirTags, fearing recurring fees or subscriptions. This misunderstanding likely stems from confusion with GPS-based pet trackers, which often require monthly payments.

In reality, AirTags have no monthly fees or subscriptions. You only need to pay the initial purchase price, which covers the device itself. After purchasing your AirTag and pairing it with your iPhone, there are no hidden costs or additional fees to worry about.

If you're curious about other common AirTag questions, our article Apple AirTag for Dogs: What Owners Need to Know provides comprehensive insights.

Myth #3: AirTags are Completely Waterproof

There's a common belief that AirTags are fully waterproof and suitable for continuous swimming. However, this isn't entirely true.

Apple officially rates AirTags as water-resistant (IP67), meaning they can withstand being submerged in up to 1 meter (approximately 3 feet) of water for a maximum of 30 minutes. They're designed for occasional splashes, rain, or brief accidental submersion, not for extended swimming sessions.

If your dog regularly swims or enjoys water-based activities, it's advisable to use additional protective measures or consider collars designed specifically for aquatic activities. Understanding these limitations ensures you avoid potential damage to your AirTag.

Myth #4: Any Collar or Holder is Safe for AirTags

One of the most dangerous myths is assuming that any cheap holder or collar can safely secure an AirTag. Poor-quality holders can easily come loose, creating hazards for your dog.

Some cheap holders allow AirTags to dangle or swing freely, increasing the risk of the tag catching on branches, fences, or furniture. In extreme cases, loosely secured AirTags can fall off and be swallowed by curious dogs, requiring emergency veterinary attention.

To prevent this, always choose collars specifically designed for AirTags, with secure, built-in compartments or pockets. Our guide, AirTag Dog Collar Holder Guide: What Actually Works and Stays Put, provides valuable recommendations on safe holders and collars.

Close-up of a leather AirTag dog collar securely holding an Apple AirTag

Myth #5: AirTags Replace the Need for Microchipping

Another widespread misconception is that AirTags can replace traditional microchips. Although AirTags are a useful tracking tool, they don't replace permanent identification methods like microchipping.

Microchips are embedded beneath your dog's skin and serve as permanent identification. If your dog ever becomes lost and someone finds them without access to an Apple device, traditional microchips or ID tags provide a universally accessible method to contact you.

Microchipping greatly increases the likelihood of a lost dog being returned home safely, with over 50% of lost dogs returned with microchips (compared to 20% without). Therefore, the best practice for your dog's safety involves combining an AirTag with microchipping and traditional ID tags.

Myth #6: AirTags Provide Real-Time Tracking

It's common for pet owners to think that AirTags offer live, real-time location updates like traditional GPS trackers. However, this isn't exactly how AirTags work.

AirTags use Bluetooth and Apple's Find My network. Instead of continuously broadcasting your dog's live location, an AirTag sends its location periodically whenever an Apple device comes within its Bluetooth range. This means the AirTag doesn’t require WiFi connectivity to work, and you receive periodic updates rather than instant, continuous tracking.

For most city or suburban dog owners, this periodic updating provides sufficient peace of mind, as there’s usually an abundance of Apple devices nearby to update your AirTag’s location. However, if your dog frequently wanders off or you live in remote areas, AirTags alone might not provide the frequent updates you desire. In such cases, pairing your AirTag with a traditional GPS tracker may be a better solution.

Myth #7: AirTags Drain Your Phone’s Battery Quickly

A surprising myth is that using AirTags with your iPhone rapidly drains your phone's battery. The truth is, AirTags have very minimal impact on your phone's battery life.

AirTags themselves use a small, replaceable coin battery that typically lasts around a year. They do not constantly communicate directly with your phone. Instead, AirTags connect briefly when you're using the Find My app or when they're within Bluetooth range.

Because the AirTag relies primarily on nearby devices within Apple's network to communicate its location, your phone isn't continuously managing or maintaining that connection. Apple's official documentation confirms that AirTags do not significantly impact iPhone battery performance.

Myth #8: AirTags Only Work with Newer iPhones

Many pet owners hesitate to adopt AirTags, mistakenly thinking they need the latest iPhone model for compatibility. However, AirTags work effectively with many older iPhone models too.

Specifically, AirTags are compatible with iPhones running iOS 14.5 or later. That includes devices dating back several years, such as the iPhone 6s and later. If you're unsure about your phone’s compatibility, simply check your iOS version in your phone’s settings.

This broad compatibility makes AirTags an accessible solution for most iPhone users, even if your device isn’t brand new. Always ensure your iPhone is running the latest software updates for the best tracking performance.

Myth #9: AirTags Only Work Near Your Own Phone

Another frequent misconception is that AirTags can only communicate with your own iPhone, limiting their usefulness significantly. This isn't true. In fact, the real power behind AirTags comes from Apple's vast Find My network, which includes over a billion iPhones globally.

When your dog’s AirTag goes out of your personal Bluetooth range, other Apple devices nearby can anonymously detect and update its location, allowing you to track your dog even when you're far away, no matter how far away (even when on the other side of the world). This community-powered approach is one of AirTag’s biggest advantages and significantly expands their tracking potential.

Myth #10: You Don't Need to Test or Check Your AirTag Regularly

Some pet owners mistakenly assume that AirTags are a "set-it-and-forget-it" solution that requires no ongoing attention. While AirTags are indeed easy to use, regular maintenance and occasional testing are essential.

For instance, the coin battery inside an AirTag typically lasts about a year, after which you need to replace it. Additionally, periodically checking your AirTag's connection through the Find My app ensures it continues to function correctly and hasn’t suffered damage or malfunction.

Veterinarians and animal safety experts consistently recommend regular checks of all pet-tracking devices and collars. This ensures they're functioning properly and keeping your pet safe. Regular inspections are particularly important for the collar and holder you use, as even small wear-and-tear can compromise security.

Be proactive in checking your AirTag and collar regularly, ideally monthly, to guarantee it continues offering reliable protection for your dog.

woman using find my app to track her dog

Myth #11: AirTags Are Too Heavy for Smaller Dogs

Another myth circulating among dog owners is that AirTags are too large or heavy for puppies and small breeds. AirTags are small, lightweight devices, weighing approximately 0.39 ounces (11 grams), about the size of a coin. Most small dogs or puppies can comfortably wear them without any issues, provided they're secured properly.

The real concern isn’t the weight of the AirTag, but rather the collar and attachment method. Choosing a collar specifically designed for AirTags ensures it sits flush against your dog’s neck and doesn't cause discomfort or irritation. Proper sizing and placement prevent your pet from noticing or being bothered by the AirTag.

For reassurance, veterinarians generally recommend collars and attachments that distribute weight evenly and comfortably around your dog's neck. Choosing the right-sized collar, like our Leather AirTag Dog Collar, specifically designed to be comfortable and securely hold the AirTag, ensures optimal comfort and safety.

Myth #12: AirTags Eliminate the Need for Training and Recall Commands

Some pet parents mistakenly believe that using AirTags means they no longer need to train their dogs for recall or basic obedience commands. Unfortunately, this is a dangerous misconception.

While AirTags significantly boost the chances of quickly locating a lost dog, they don't replace foundational training. Basic recall and obedience commands remain critical in ensuring your dog's safety. Training helps reduce the likelihood of your dog becoming lost in the first place and ensures that your dog responds to your calls in potentially hazardous situations.

According to dog training experts and veterinarians, a well-trained dog who reliably responds to recall commands is much safer overall. AirTags should be viewed as an additional layer of security, not a replacement for proper training and responsible pet ownership.

If you’re interested in improving your dog’s recall, see our detailed post on How to Get Your Dog to Listen.

FAQs About AirTag Dog Collars

Do AirTags require a monthly subscription?
No, AirTags have no subscription fees. You only pay the initial purchase price.

Can AirTags track dogs in real-time?
No, AirTags provide periodic location updates based on proximity to Apple devices. They do not offer continuous real-time tracking.

Are AirTags safe for puppies and small breeds?
Yes, AirTags weigh about 0.39 ounces and are suitable for small dogs and puppies when paired with properly sized collars.

How long does an AirTag’s battery last?
An AirTag battery typically lasts about one year and is easily replaceable.

Do AirTags drain my iPhone battery quickly?
No, AirTags minimally impact your iPhone's battery, as they primarily rely on their own internal battery and nearby Apple devices.

Should AirTags replace microchips and ID tags?
Absolutely not. AirTags enhance your dog’s safety but should always be used alongside traditional identification methods like microchips and ID tags.

Can my dog swim with an AirTag collar?
Brief exposure to water is safe due to the AirTag's IP67 water-resistance rating, but extended swimming or submersion should be avoided.

Final Thoughts: Keeping Your Dog Safe with AirTags

AirTag collars offer dog owners a practical, affordable, and effective way to track their beloved pets. Understanding and dispelling common myths helps ensure you use them correctly and safely. Always pair your AirTag with a high-quality collar designed specifically for this purpose, regularly maintain the device, and continue emphasizing foundational training and recall commands.

By clarifying these myths, you can confidently harness the benefits of AirTags and enhance your dog’s overall safety and well-being.

Back to blog